asl search
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Search in posts
Search in pages
guides
products
Filter by Categories
Anti-Snoring Reviews
Bedding
Bedding Information
Bedding Reviews
Best Bed Frames
Best Comforters
Best Mattress
Best Mattress Pads
Best Mattress Protectors
Best Mattress Toppers
Best Pillowcases
Best Pillows
Best Sheets
Interviews
Mattress Accessories
Mattress Comparisons
Mattress Coupons
Mattress Information
Mattress Reviews
Mattress Sales
Mattress Sizes
Mattress Topper Reviews
Pillow Reviews
Sheet Reviews
Sleep
Sleep Environment
Sleep Products
Sleep Tracker Reviews
Uncategorized
Weighted Blanket Reviews
Our editors test & choose the products we write about. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn More.
Tuck Sleep > Best Mattress > Best Mattresses of 2023 – Top Picks & Buyer’s Guide

Best Mattresses of 2023 – Top Picks & Buyer’s Guide

Written by Tuck Staff

Quick Overview

Choosing the best mattress for you depends on a whole mix of factors: your favorite sleep position, your body weight, whether you sleep alone or with a partner, your budget, your current health conditions, and even whether you tend to run hot or cold. It’s a lot to consider.

It doesn’t necessarily help that there are truly hundreds of mattresses to choose from. While it’s nice to have options, it makes it difficult to hone in on the best mattress for you.

That’s why we set out to make the mattress buying process easier. Based on years of testing, extensive mattress knowledge, and data-backed research, we’ve narrowed down your list of options to the top ten mattresses available today. No matter your sleep position, budget, or mattress preference, you’ll find a match for you here.

Our Methodology: How’d we decide on these top ten mattresses? We put these mattresses to the test ourselves. Having slept on, tested, and reviewed hundreds of beds (and cross-referencing our analysis with hundreds of thousands of customer experience data points), these are the beds that stand out. You can learn more about our research process here.

The Best Mattresses of 2022
First Time Buying a Mattress?

Hop down to our Buyer’s Guide for a crash course on finding the best mattress for you.

 

The Best Mattresses – Reviewed

Best OverallSaatva Classic

Best Overall - Saatva Classic

Highlights

  • Multiple firmness options (4, 6, 7.5)
  • 365-night sleep trial
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Coil-on-coil construction offers balance of comfort and support
  • Two high-profile options
Read Our Full Review
Our readers get $200 off the Saatva Classic.
Check Price

Best OverallSaatva Classic

saatva.com

Shop Now

Thanks to an innovative coil-on-coil construction, the Saatva Classic manages to do what many innersprings can’t: offer a higher level of contouring pressure relief, while still maintaining the durable, supportive and responsive qualities that make innerspring beds popular.

The Saatva Classic uses strong, steel-tempered bonnell coils in its support core. These provide even support throughout the mattress, whether you’re sleeping in the middle or sitting on the edge. They also keep the mattress sleeping cool, thanks to ample airflow. On top, comfort layers of memory foam, polyfoam, and pocketed coils provide contouring and pressure relief for sleepers.

With three firmness settings and two thickness profiles, the Saatva Classic caters to a wide range of sleepers. Sleepers can choose among ‘Medium Soft’ (4), ‘Medium Firm’ (6), and ‘Firm’ (7.5) settings based on their sleep position and body weight. Those who prefer a higher-profile bed can choose between 11.5- and 14.5-inch profiles.

Saatva also offers a long list of perks to attract mattress shoppers, whether their concerns are ease of setup, flexible returns, or long-term durability. Free White Glove delivery is baked into the cost of the mattress (this service typically costs at least $100), and it’s backed by a 365-night sleep trial and lifetime warranty.

The Bottom Line.

The Saatva Classic was built with quality, comfort, and support in mind—and it delivers. This mattress keeps hot sleepers cool, provides a responsive surface for sex, and ensures healthy spinal alignment for most sleep positions and body types.

  • Every type of sleeper (side, back, stomach, combination). The ‘Medium Firm’ is a common firmness setting that’s comfortable for most sleepers, although sleepers can choose a softer or firmer setting to better suit their sleep position.
  • Sleepers in all weight groups (light, average, heavy). The Saatva Classic’s thick profile and durable innerspring core ensures adequate support for most body weights, with softer firmness settings to accommodate lightweight sleepers.
  • Those who tend to sleep hot. The Saatva Classic’s innerspring design promotes airflow and keeps the mattress surface cool throughout the night.
  • Value seekers. The Saatva Classic features a high-end construction without the price tag to match.

Not Recommended for:

  • Those who prefer a traditional memory foam feel. While the Saatva Classic offers more conforming than the average innerspring bed, it’s no match for an all-foam bed.
  • Sleepers who wake easily from noise or movement. Like many innerspring beds, the Saatva Classic doesn’t isolate motion very well, so there’s a potential for movement and noise whenever you or a sleep partner shift positions during the night.

Most ComfortableLuxury Firm WinkBed

Most Comfortable - Luxury Firm WinkBed

Highlights

  • Medium firm (6)
  • 120-night sleep trial
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Excellent responsiveness and edge support
  • Zoned support system relieves back pain
Read Our Full Review
Get $200 off a WinkBed mattress with code: TUCK200.
See Lowest Price

Most ComfortableLuxury Firm WinkBed

winkbeds.com

Shop Now

The Luxury Firm WinkBed earns its spot on our list thanks to its next-level hybrid design, which combines an innerspring support core with thick comfort layers of polyfoam. The WinkBed is available in multiple firmness levels, but the Luxury Firm offers a medium firm (6) feel that delivers the most comfortable balance of cushioning and support.

The plush comfort layers minimize many of the common complaints people have about traditional innersprings, such as their high noise potential and lack of pressure point relief. Instead, the Luxury Firm WinkBed offers above-average conforming and pain relief for individuals with chronic pain in the lower back or hips. Individuals also enjoy a quieter sleep experience with this mattress thanks to silencing layers of memory foam above the coil support core.

The WinkBed ships free throughout the U.S. The mattress also comes with a 120-night sleep trial and lifetime warranty.

The Bottom Line.

The hybrid design of the Luxury Firm WinkBed enables this mattress to appeal to a variety of sleepers, regardless of their body type or sleep position. Hot sleepers, people with chronic pain , and couples can all enjoy a good night’s sleep.

  • People who weigh 230 pounds or less. The Luxury Firm WinkBed’s hybrid design is particularly well suited for side, back, and stomach sleepers who weigh up to 230 pounds.
  • Hot sleepers. A breathable cover and steady air circulation through the coil system allow the Luxury Firm WinkBed to sleep quite cool.
  • Couples. The Luxury Firm WinkBed absorbs motion fairly well and has a responsive surface suitable for sex.
  • Back and hip pain sufferers. The zoned support system maximizes the supportive and pressure-relieving qualities of the mattress.

Not Recommended for…

  • Back and stomach sleepers who weigh more than 230 pounds. Although the Luxury Firm WinkBed offers robust support, the mattress may feel too soft for back and stomach sleepers weighing more than 230 pounds.
  • Shoppers who want to be able to return their mattress quickly if needed. The WinkBed includes a mandatory 30-night break-in period with their sleep trial.

Best ValueNectar Mattress

Best Value - Nectar Mattress

Highlights

  • 'Medium Firm' (6)
  • 365-night sleep trial
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Memory foam mattress sleeps relatively cool
  • Below-average price-point
Read Our Full Review
Our readers get $100 OFF any Nectar Mattress + 2 Free pillows!

Code = TUCK

Claim Discount

Best ValueNectar Mattress

nectarsleep.com

Shop Now

The Nectar mattress consistently rates as one of our Best Value picks for mattresses. This bed boasts a high-quality memory foam construction that cradles pressure points, sleeps quiet, and costs much less than the average all-foam bed. Plus, the ‘Medium Firm’ feel comfortably accommodates most sleepers of average weight, regardless of their sleep position.

The Nectar mattress measures 12 inches thick, with support layers of high-density polyfoam and a memory foam comfort layer. The end result is a highly conforming sleep experience that adapts to the sleeper’s body and provides pain and pressure relief.

Despite all those layers of foam, the Nectar manages to sleep cool, too. The cover and the top comfort layer both feature cooling materials to regulate the mattress temperature, including breathable cotton and Tencel® lyocell in the cover and gel in the memory foam.

The Nectar mattress ships free anywhere in the contiguous U.S. Nectar offers a 365-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty, both of which are much longer than industry averages.

The Bottom Line.

If you’re looking for that memory foam feel, but want to sleep cool and enjoy a great deal at the same time, you’ll find it with the Nectar mattress.

  • Any type of sleeper, especially side and back sleepers. Memory foam in the comfort layers adapt to the sleeper’s body, allowing heavier parts of the body to sink deeper into the mattress and maintain good spinal alignment.
  • Sleepers in the average and heavy weight groups (130 pounds or more). The ‘Medium Firm’ firmness of the Nectar will feel most comfortable for these sleepers.
  • Couples. As a memory foam bed, the Nectar sleeps very quiet and has virtually no motion transfer.
  • Value seekers. The Nectar mattress should last just as long, and sleep just as comfortably, as comparable memory foam beds, even though it has a much lower price-point.

Not Recommended for:

  • Lightweight sleepers. These folks may find a softer mattress more comfortable.
  • Those who prefer to sleep “on” rather than “in” their mattress. As a memory foam bed, the Nectar conforms closely to the body and provides a body-hugging sensation.

Best for Side SleepersLayla Mattress

Best for Side Sleepers - Layla Mattress

Highlights

  • Flippable with dual firmness (4, 7)
  • 120-night sleep trial
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Great motion isolation
  • Close conforming and pressure relief
Read Our Full Review
SAve $110 on a new Layla Mattress.

Code = TUCK

Claim Discount

Best for Side SleepersLayla Mattress

laylasleep.com

Shop Now

Many sleepers have firmness preferences that change from night to night. The Layla Mattress addresses these needs with a flippable design that features a different firmness on each side. One side is ‘Medium Soft’ (4 on the 1-10 firmness scale), and the other side is ‘Firm’ (7).

Having two choices enables sleepers to find just the right fit based on their comfort preferences while knowing that either option will cushion their pressure points.

Both sides of the mattress have copper-infused memory foam comfort layers. This material conforms closely to the sleeper’s body in order to improve spinal alignment and minimize pressure points. The ‘Medium Soft’ side has an additional layer of convoluted polyfoam for extra cushioning. The shared middle layer made of high-density polyfoam ensures an even, supportive sleep surface.

The Layla Mattress also minimizes and reduces motion transfer to a significant extent, and is virtually silent when bearing weight. For these reasons, the mattress is suitable for couples – particularly if one or both of the sleepers awaken easily due to movement or noise. The mattress is also quite light, making it easy to flip for most people.

Layla Sleep ships mattresses anywhere in the U.S. and Canada, and customers in the contiguous U.S. qualify for free delivery. The mattress is backed by a 120-night sleep trial, which is longer than average, as well as a lifetime warranty.

The Bottom Line

The Layla Mattress offers two firmnesses in one mattress, making it suitable for a wide range of sleeper types. It excels at pressure relief and motion isolation and is very competitively priced.

  • Sleepers who prefer the “hug” of memory foam. The Layla offers a traditional memory foam feel on both sides.
  • Those seeking adjustable firmness options. Sleepers can easily change the firmness of the bed by flipping it over.
  • Individuals who share the bed with a partner. The bed’s all foam construction minimizes motion transfer and noise, making it a great choice for those who share the bed with an easily awakened partner.
  • People who weigh 230 pounds or less. Sleepers of all position preferences rated the bed highly in the light and average weight groups.

Not Recommended for:

  • Individuals who prefer a more responsive feel. Due to its memory foam comfort layers and foam core, the Layla Mattress is not very springy or bouncy.
  • Those who weigh over 230 pounds. Heavyweight sleepers are unlikely to receive the support they need for proper spinal alignment from this all-foam model.
  • People who need strong edge support to comfortably get in and out of bed. The Layla’s all-foam construction is not able to offer strong edge support, which means the perimeter of the mattress will sag noticeably when sleepers sit or lie near the edge of the bed.

Best for Back PainHelix Sleep

Best for Back Pain - Helix Sleep

Highlights

  • Three firmness options and two foam types available
  • 100-night sleep trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Balance of conforming and support
  • Great temperature neutrality
Read Our Full Review
Our readers get the best price available on the Helix Mattress
Check Price

Best for Back PainHelix Sleep

helixsleep.com

Shop Now

Helix Sleep’s line of hybrid mattresses offers a versatility perhaps unmatched in the sleep industry. Their six hybrid beds can be divided into two categories, memory foam hybrids and Dynamic Foam hybrids, the latter being their proprietary polyfoam. Both of these lines include three firmness levels, and all of these mattresses can be upgraded to a ‘Luxe’ version, which features a pillow top.

The memory foam hybrids, consisting of the Helix Sunset, Midnight, and Twilight, offer significant pressure relief, easing pressure points and reducing pain issues. The Dynamic foam models, the Moonlight, Dusk, and Dawn, feature a more responsive and supportive comfort layer that provides a more even sleep surface. All Helix models contain a substantial pocketed coil support core, which keeps the mattress cool by allowing airflow and provides significant support.

Helix’s high customizable product line ensures that sleepers of all body types and preferred positions can find a bed to suit their needs. Further, they all come at a below-average price-point for a hybrid mattress. Helix offers a 100 night sleep trial and a 10 year warranty, and ships free to anywhere in the US.

  • Every type of sleeper (side, back, stomach, combination). With three firmness levels to choose from and both memory foam and Dynamic foam available, every sleeper should find a version to suit them.
  • Sleepers in all weight groups (light, average, heavy). Lighter sleepers should opt for the softer Helix mattresses, while heavier sleepers should go firmner
  • Hot sleepers. A pocketed coil support core and gel-infused form ensure this mattress sleeps cool.
  • Shoppers who want a hybrid mattress on a budget. Helix mattresses are less expensive than most hybrid beds.

Not Recommended for:

  • Those looking for a mattress to last over seven years. The Helix mattress is somewhat durable, but likely won’t last more than the average lifespan of a mattress.

Best for Spinal AlignmentNolah Evolution 15

Best for Spinal Alignment - Nolah Evolution 15

Highlights

  • Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (8)
  • 120-night sleep trial
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Zoned coil system provides targeted support
  • Triple layers of foam offer pressure relief
Our readers get the best price available on the Nolah Evolution
Check Price

Best for Spinal AlignmentNolah Evolution 15

nolahmattress.com

Shop Now

The Nolah Evolution 15 is a hybrid bed that carefully balances support and pressure relief. Available in three firmness levels, the mattress optimizes proper sleep posture by keeping the head, neck, and spine aligned in a wide range of sleepers.

The mattress has a polyfoam layer quilted into the top, followed by two more polyfoam layers beneath. This comfort system closely cushions the body, providing relief to areas of high pressure buildup like the spine, shoulders, and hips. Beneath is a transitional layer of high-density foam to prevent the body from sinking in, and then a coil system that provides strong support, especially in the lumbar region.

Available in a medium (5), medium firm (6), and firm (8), the mattress should feel comfortable for many different body types. Side and back sleepers may prefer the medium or medium firm options, while stomach sleepers will probably find the firm most comfortable. Regardless of firmness level, this bed sleeps very cool thanks to the ample air circulation through the coils. The foam layers are also designed with cooling features to combat some of the heat retention that foam is known for.

Nolah offers a 120-night sleep trial for customers to try out the mattress. Those who choose to keep the mattress receive a lifetime warranty. Shipping is free to the contiguous U.S.

The Bottom Line.

The Nolah Evolution 15 is a well-rounded mattress available in three different firmness options. It excels at balancing support and pressure relief for a wide variety of body types.

  • Back sleepers. All sleep positions should find a compatible firmness option, but the Evolution offers a perfect balance of support and cushioning that is especially well suited for many back sleepers.
  • People with painful pressure points. The three foam layers cradle the body to help relieve pressure buildup.
  • Sleepers over 130 pounds. While this bed caters to all weight categories, people above 130 pounds are especially likely to benefit from the bed’s design.
  • Hot sleepers. Air circulation through the coils helps minimize the amount of heat this mattress will trap.

Not Recommended for:

  • People who enjoy a deep body hug. The polyfoam offers excellent cushion but does not provide the deep body hug that you would receive from a bed made entirely of memory foam.
  • Sleepers who prioritize motion isolation. While the foam layers absorb a fair amount of motion, the coils still permit some motion transfer across the surface.

  • People who weigh up to 230 pounds. The Zoma Hybrid features a memory foam comfort layer that contours somewhat closely, making the mattress best suited to lightweight and average weight sleepers who enjoy the body-cradling of medium-feel memory foam.
  • Side and back sleepers. The Zoma Hybrid’s foam layers cushion the shoulders and hips, which can improve spinal alignment and reduce pressure for side sleepers, while back sleepers can rest comfortably on an even plane without sinking too deeply.
  • Hot sleepers. The Zoma Hybrid is built with a pocketed coil system that generates steady air circulation and a ventilated cover to ensure cool, comfortable sleep for most people who run warm in bed.
  • Value seekers. The Zoma Hybrid has a price-point that is significantly below-average for a hybrid mattress.

Not Recommended for:

  • People who weigh more than 230 pounds. Since the Zoma Hybrid contours closely to the body, heavyweight sleepers are more likely to sink excessively and experience discomfort on this mattress.
  • Sleepers who prefer very responsive mattresses. The coils provide some surface-level springiness for the Zoma Hybrid, but those who would rather sleep on an exceptionally bouncy bed may find traditional innersprings more comfortable instead.

Best for Pressure ReliefTuft & Needle Mint

Best for Pressure Relief - Tuft & Needle Mint

Highlights

  • Medium Firm (6)
  • 100-night sleep trial
  • 10-year warranty
  • Below-average price-point
  • Excellent pressure relief
Read Our Full Review
Get the best price on a Tuft & Needle Mint Mattress.
Get Discount

Best for Pressure ReliefTuft & Needle Mint

tuftandneedle.com

Shop Now

The all-foam Tuft & Needle Mint features a comfort layer infused with gel and graphite, a transitional layer infused with gel, and a high-density polyfoam support core. This construction delivers excellent pressure relief and a surface that conforms to the body but offers more responsiveness than memory foam. Additionally, the Tuft & Needle Mint costs well below the average price for an all-foam mattress,making it a high-value pick for budget-minded shoppers.

The mattress has a medium-firm feel that appeals to many sleepers, especially those who want some conforming, but not too much. The bed’s thick comfort layers do a great job absorbing motion and make no noise when sleepers change positions, making this bed a great choice for those who share the bed with a light-sleeping partner.

This mattress offers better temperature neutrality than many competing all-foam models due to the low-density foams used in the comfort and transitional layers.  These same layers offer ample cushioning for side sleepers of all weight groups. Sleepers of all sleep positions rated the bed very favorably in both the lightweight and average weight categories. The bed also offers better durability than most similarly constructed models on the market.

Another notable feature is the cover. An antimicrobial agent embedded in the cover fabric is designed to keep harmful bacteria off of the mattress, and the cover’s top half can be zipped off and machine washed. The T&N Mint ships for free anywhere within the contiguous U.S., with optional White Glove delivery for an additional fee. The mattress is backed by a 100-night sleep trial and 10-year warranty.

The Bottom Line.

The Tuft & Needle Mint is an incredible value for the price. This mattress offers exceptional pressure relief and motion isolation, and should last significantly longer than most similarly constructed models.

  • Those who share a bed. The bed’s thick comfort layers and all-foam construction effectively limit motion transfer and remain quiet when sleepers move around, making this mattress ideal for couples.
  • Budget shoppers. Priced considerably lower than most similarly constructed models, this bed is a high-value pick for shoppers on a budget.
  • Anyone weighing less than 230 pounds. The Mint Mattress has received favorable ratings from sleepers in all weight groups, but especially high scores from those in the light and average weight groups.
  • Those who typically find all-foam beds too warm. The Mint Mattress’ low-density comfort and transitional layers trap less heat than the denser foams used in many competing models.

Not Recommended for:

  • Those who prefer a responsive sleep surface. The polyfoam layers in the Mint Mattress do lend some bounce to the bed’s surface, but not as much as hybrid and innerspring models.
  • Stomach sleepers over 230 pounds. This group gave this mattress the lowest scores, citing a lack of proper support for the midsection. Sagging in this area can cause the spine to fall out of alignment and lead to next-day discomfort.

Best CoolingBear Original

Best Cooling - Bear Original

Highlights

  • 'Firm' (7)
  • 120-night sleep trial
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Supportive, firm surface
  • Sleeps cooler than other foam beds
Read Our Full Review
Our readers save 20% on Bear mattresses.
Get Discount

Best CoolingBear Original

bearmattress.com

Shop Now

The Bear Original comes in a ‘Firm’ setting that provides optimal conforming for sleepers over 130 pounds and any sleep position. This all-foam bed made its way onto our best mattress list for its pressure-relieving feel, cooling fabric cover, and low price-point.

Like many foam beds, the Bear Mattress uses high-density polyfoam for its support core. Where this mattress stands out is its use of innovative cooling materials in its comfort layers and cover. Comfort layers of memory foam are infused with gel and graphite to enhance the mattress’s cooling capabilities and resist body heat. Better yet, the mattress cover is made of a Celliant fabric blend. This material converts body heat into infrared energy, and then back into the sleeper’s body, improving blood circulation for faster physical recovery and pain relief.

Beyond cooling, the Bear Mattress offers excellent motion isolation, so the mattress stays quiet and still even if you or your sleep partner move frequently during the night. It also provides above-average pressure relief, without completely enveloping the sleeper’s body.

The Bear Original ships free throughout the U.S. The bed is backed by a 120-night sleep trial and lifetime warranty.

The Bottom Line.

With the Bear Original, sleepers don’t have to sacrifice comfort for coolness. They can have both. This all-foam bed is designed to help sleepers physically recover while they sleep, giving them the pressure relief they need with the aid of temperature-regulating materials.

  • Back and stomach sleepers. The Bear Original is firm enough to support healthy spinal alignment for these sleep positions, while allowing the sleepers to enjoy some conforming and pressure relief.
  • Sleepers in the average and heavy weight groups. The ‘Medium Firm’ feel of the Bear Original provides the best support for sleepers of 130 pounds or more.
  • Couples. The Bear Original isolates motion very well, reducing the chance of disruptions from noise or movement during the night.
  • Athletes. The Celliant fabric cover transforms the sleeper’s body heat into infrared energy, with the effect of increasing blood flow in the muscles and tissues.

Not Recommended for:

  • Those looking for strong edge support. As with most all-foam beds, it’s common to experience sinkage when sitting on or lying close to the edges of The Bear Original.
  • Those who prefer a traditional memory foam feel. Part of what allows the Bear Original to sleep cool is that it doesn’t conform quite as closely to the body as other memory foam beds.

Best for Back SleepersLumaSleep Mattress

Best for Back Sleepers - LumaSleep Mattress

Highlights

  • Multiple firmness options (3.5, 6, 7.5)
  • 100-night sleep trial
  • 15-year warranty
  • Durable latex hybrid construction
  • Exceptional cooling and temperature control
Read Our Full Review
Buy a LumaSleep Mattress at the lowest available price.
Claim Discount

Best for Back SleepersLumaSleep Mattress

lumasleep.com

Shop Now

The LumaSleep Mattress is constructed with layers of Talalay latex and dense transitional foam over a support core of individually pocketed coils. These components give the mattress a very responsive surface feel. The hybrid is also quite breathable. Both the latex and foam layers are ventilated to promote airflow near the surface, while the coils circulate air throughout the interior to help the mattress maintain a comfortable temperature.

The LumaSleep Mattress is also a good option for people who are unsure about their ideal firmness level. Three firmness options are available: soft (3.5), medium firm (6), and firm (7.5). Those who are not satisfied with how their mattress feels can exchange their bed for a model with a different firmness during the 100-night sleep trial.

People with back pain should consider firmness levels that correspond to their body weight and primary sleep position. Lighter people – particularly side sleepers – will likely prefer the soft feel, while the medium firm and firm feels are better suited to back and stomach sleepers, as well as those who weigh more than 230 pounds.

The LumaSleep Mattress has a relatively low sticker price compared to the cost of the average latex hybrid. Luma Sleep offers free ground shipping throughout the contiguous U.S., as well as White Glove delivery that starts at $100 per order. In addition to the 100-night trial, the company also offers a 10-year warranty.

The Bottom Line.

The LumaSleep Mattress is a durable latex hybrid that offers above-average responsiveness and also sleeps exceptionally cool. Customers can choose between three distinct firmness levels based on their body type, sleep position, and personal preferences.

  • Hot sleepers. Ventilated top layers and an open coil system promote steady airflow throughout the mattress core to regulate temperature and keep sleepers cool.
  • People who prefer very responsive mattresses. The LumaSleep mattress is constructed with a latex comfort layer and pocketed coil support core, both of which make the mattress feel springy on the surface.
  • Value seekers. The price-point of this mattress is very reasonable compared to the average cost of a latex hybrid.
  • Those who are unsure which firmness level is best for them. Luma Sleep offers three different firmness options for this mattress, and customers who are not satisfied with their initial choice can exchange for different models within the 100-night sleep trial.

Not Recommended for...

  • Sleepers who prefer close body-contouring. The LumaSleep Mattress conforms a bit – especially models with soft feels – but not to the same extent as beds designed with memory foam comfort layers.
  • People who wake up easily due to their partner’s movements. While the latex comfort layer absorbs some movement, most people will feel transfer across the surface when their sleep partner changes positions of gets in and out of bed.

Best OrganicAvocado Green Mattress

Best Organic - Avocado Green Mattress

Highlights

  • Multiple firmness options (5.5, 6.5)
  • 365-night sleep trial
  • 25-year warranty
  • Organic and vegan mattress models
  • Zoned support system
Read Our Full Review
Our readers can save $150 on their Avocado Mattress with code: TUCKAVO.
Get Discount

Best OrganicAvocado Green Mattress

avocadogreenmattress.com

Shop Now

For mattress shoppers who care about the environment, it doesn’t get better than the Avocado Green Mattress. The mattress manufacturer offers two green mattress options, the Avocado Green and the Avocado Vegan, both made from sustainable, natural materials.

Each mattress is a latex hybrid, with a support core of pocketed coils made from recycled steel, sandwiched between layers of organic Dunlop latex. The mattresses feature another pillowtop layer above the latex for additional comfort and cushion: a wool layer in the case of the Avocado Green, or organic cotton in the case of the Avocado Vegan.

Together, these materials offer an optimal mix of contouring and support for a variety of sleep positions, while ensuring the mattress has a low environmental impact, sleeps cool, and lasts for a number of years.

The standard Avocado mattress measures 11 inches thick and has a ‘Medium Firm’ feel, although both can be purchased with an optional pillow top layer of organic latex. This adds another 2 inches to the mattress height and provides a plusher sleep surface, closer to a ‘Medium’ firmness rating.

Avocado mattresses ship free to the contiguous U.S., with White Glove delivery available for an additional fee. Both mattresses are backed by an extensive 25-year warranty and year-long sleep trial.

The Bottom Line.

Avocado Green mattresses were built to cater to shoppers with environmental concerns, but the end result is a mattress with wide consumer appeal. These mattresses sleep very cool, provide a good mix of bounce, contouring, and support, and last significantly longer than the average mattress.

  • Every type of sleeper (side, back, stomach, combination). Side sleepers can choose the thicker pillow-top option for a plusher feel, while back and stomach sleepers may find the standard 11-inch profile to be most comfortable.
  • Sleepers in the average and heavy weight groups. With ‘Medium’ and ‘Medium Firm’ options, either Avocado Green mattress should comfortably support sleepers weighing 130 pounds or more.
  • Eco-conscious shoppers. Both Avocado Green mattresses are handmade in the U.S.A. from natural, organic, and recycled materials. The Avocado Vegan mattress swaps out the layer of wool for cotton, offering vegan customers a fully cruelty-free construction.
  • Hot sleepers. All-natural materials like Dunlop latex, breathable cotton, and moisture-wicking wool keep the mattress temperature cool throughout the night.

Not Recommended for:

  • Lightweight sleepers. Dunlop latex has a firmer feel that may create pressure points for sleepers in this weight group, especially if they sleep on their side.
  • Those who prefer a traditional memory foam feel. Dunlop latex provides some conforming and pressure relief, but not to the extent of an all-foam bed.

Mattress Buying Guides and Research

Looking for a more specific mattress type, price point, ailment/sleep issue, or just want to dig deeper in your mattress search? Browse one of our in-depth mattress guides to help make an informed decision.

By Mattress Type

By Sleeper Type

For Specific Needs

By Price

By Mattress Feel

By Size

Best Mattresses Buying Guide

When purchasing a new mattress, it can be useful to ask yourself a few key questions to help you evaluate your mattress options, and choose the best mattress for you. For example, do you prefer a softer or firmer feel? Is pressure relief a primary concern, or are you more focused on sleeping cool through the night? How much would you like to spend?

Below, we walk you through these questions and more. Our five-step buyer’s guide helps you navigate everything you need to consider when buying a new mattress, from your personal sleep preferences and health needs to mattress construction and price.

Mattress Buyer’s Guide: Your 5-Step Plan

Step 1: What’s Your Preferred Sleep Position?

Want to enjoy a good night’s sleep? We’ll let you in on a secret. The best mattress for you depends on one key element: how well it keeps your spine aligned while you sleep. Among other things, your body uses sleep as a time for recovery. To do that effectively, your spine needs to stay aligned, so your body can focus on repairing your muscles and tissues — instead of dealing with aches and pains from spinal misalignment.

Depending on your sleep position, you’ll need different levels of conforming from your mattress to enjoy healthy spinal alignment. Take a look at the images below to see what we mean.

spine alignment during sleep back sleeping spine alignment stomach sleeping spinal alignment

In reality, most people are combination sleepers. We change positions throughout the night to stay comfortable. But, it’s likely you have a preference for one position over another. This is the position you initially fall asleep in, and it’s the one you can use as a guide when choosing a new mattress.

  • Side sleepers require a softer mattress that allows their hips and shoulders to sink deeper into the mattress surface. Mattresses with highly conforming comfort layers, like those found in memory foam and hybrid mattresses, can provide great support.
  • Back sleepers don’t require quite as much conforming as side sleepers. They need a mattress with a nice, middle-of-the-road level of conforming. Their hips and shoulders need to be able to sink deeper into the mattress, but not so deeply as to cause an uncomfortable curvature in their spine. Zoned support systems, such as those found in hybrids, can be ideal for this sleep position. Firmer all-foam beds, airbeds, and innersprings with plush comfort layers can also be comfortable.
  • Stomach sleepers require the least amount of conforming. Stomach sleepers typically find firmer mattresses to be the most comfortable, as these prevent their pelvis from sinking too deeply and out of alignment. Firmer hybrid mattresses and innerspring beds can be good choices.

Step 2: Determine Your Ideal Firmness Level

One easy way to think of mattress firmness is with a 1-to-10 scale, with 1 being the softest and 10 being the firmest. Most mattresses today fall between a 3 (‘Soft’) and an 8 (‘Firm’).

We alluded to this in the previous section, but your ideal mattress firmness depends partly on your sleep position. It also depends on your body weight.

recommended mattress firmness by body weight

A person of average weight (between 130 to 230 pounds) typically finds a mattress right in the middle of the firmness range, such as a 5 or 6, to be most comfortable. Whether they prefer a true Medium, or something slightly firmer or softer, depends on personal preference and their sleep position. For example, an average-weight side sleeper may lean toward a ‘Medium’ (5) while an average-weight stomach sleeper may prefer a ‘Medium-Firm’ (6).

People of above-average weight (230 pounds or more) generally find firmer mattresses to be more supportive, such as a ‘Firm’ (7) or firmer. Firmer mattresses do a better job preventing their body from sinking too deeply into the bed, while being built well enough to resist sagging or body indentations.

People of below-average weight (130 pounds or less) usually enjoy the most comfort from softer mattresses, with ratings of ‘Medium Soft’ (4) or lower. These beds allow them to sink sufficiently into the mattress surface to experience pressure relief and proper spinal alignment.

Below, we share the commonly preferred firmness ratings for each sleep position and weight group. However, your mileage may vary. What’s important is finding a mattress that feels comfortable for you to sleep on, whether or not it fits within the “normal” firmness range.

Step 3: Consider Other Health or Lifestyle Needs

Once you know your preferred firmness level, you can pretty much get started shopping for a new mattress. You just need to look for one that feels comfortable and fits within that firmness range.

But some people are looking for a little something more from their mattress, whether it’s pain relief or a suitable surface for sex. We review these additional considerations below.

  • Do You Suffer From Chronic Pain?

    Many people live with chronic pain, whether from a physical injury or health condition like arthritis. These people need a mattress that relieves their pain, so they can go about their day with as few aches and pains as possible.

    Memory foam mattresses can be ideal for these sleepers, as this highly conforming material is engineered to cradle the body and relieve pressure. Hybrid and latex models with several inches of memory foam in their comfort layers can also provide a good mix of conforming and support. For more, review our guides to the best mattresses for back pain, shoulder pain, and hip pain.

  • Do You Tend to Sleep Hot?

    Some people are hot sleepers. They may have a larger body type, be going through menopause, or simply tend to run hot, Whatever the reason, it’s no fun to wake up feeling sweaty or warm.

    If you identify as one of these hot sleepers, we have good news: many mattresses are constructed with cooling materials. For example, all-latex and green mattresses are mostly made from organic, naturally more breathable materials like latex, cotton, or wool.

    Innerspring mattresses are also a good choice for hot sleepers. These beds tend to sleep the coolest of all mattresses since they allow for ample airflow in their coil support core. However, if you don’t like the feel of an innerspring bed, you can still enjoy a cool night’s sleep with the right materials. Instead of traditional polyfoam or memory foam (both of which can trap heat), all-foam and hybrid mattresses may infuse their comfort layers with graphite, gel, or copper to help regulate the mattress temperature.

    Independent of material composition, firmer mattresses also provide relief for hot sleepers. Because these mattresses provide minimal conforming, there’s less potential for the person to sink into the mattress surface and trap their body heat.

  • Do You Sleep with a Partner or Pet?

    People who share their bed with a partner or pet have additional requirements for their mattress, such as good motion isolation. Motion isolation refers to how well the mattress absorbs motion. If you’re a light sleeper and share your bed with someone who moves often during the night, motion isolation can be the difference between a good night’s sleep and a bad one.

    All-foam beds provide superior motion isolation when bearing weight. Innerspring beds, on the other hand, have a noisier sleep surface due to their coil support core.

    However, that coil support core also makes innerspring mattresses especially suitable for sex, which can be another consideration for couples. Couples looking for a reasonable mix of responsiveness and motion isolation can find it with hybrid or latex beds. These aren’t quite as quiet as all-foam mattresses, but provide a similar bounce to innersprings.

  • Are You Physically Active?

    Like those with chronic pain, athletes and physically active individuals can require more recovery while they sleep. These folks may prefer a mattress with above-average pressure relief, such as that offered by memory foam beds.

    However, physically active individuals can also run hotter than others. A mattress with strong temperature neutrality, such as a latex or latex-hybrid, can help them sleep cool through the night.

    Additionally, some mattresses are constructed with materials specifically designed to hasten physical recovery. Celliant fabric covers, for example, convert the sleeper’s body heat into infrared energy, before transmitting it back to the sleeper through their skin to boost tissue oxygenation and blood flow. Copper-infused comfort layers may also improve blood circulation.

Step 4: Explore Mattress Type and Materials

In the previous steps, you figured out the type of support and comfort qualities you need from a mattress, based on your sleep position, health needs, and personal preferences. Finally, it’s time to put all this together and find the mattress that’s designed to accommodate these preferences.

Best Innerspring Mattresses

Mattress Reviews
Saatva Mattress Review

Innerspring Mattresses

Innerspring mattresses use steel coils as their support system, topped by comfort layers of foam, memory foam, latex foam, or minicoils.

Our testing shows these mattresses are ideal for:

Hot sleepers. Innerspring mattresses have excellent temperature neutrality, due to freely flowing air throughout the support core. With less conforming in their comfort layers, there’s also less potential for trapping body heat.

Those looking for even support. The innerspring coils provide uniform support across the mattress.

Those who want a minimal amount of conforming. The amount of memory foam in the comfort layers, and the thickness of the comfort layers, can increase the conforming of an innerspring mattress, but generally these mattresses have minimal conforming.

Those who want a responsive surface for sex. Innerspring mattresses are bouncy and suitable for sex.

Budget shoppers. Innerspring mattresses are widely available and one of the more affordable mattress types.

Best Foam Mattresses

Mattress Reviews
Casper Mattress Review
Mattress Reviews
Nectar Mattress Review
Mattress Reviews
Bear Mattress Review

Foam Mattresses

Foam mattresses use high-density polyfoam in their support layer, with comfort layers of polyfoam or memory foam.

Our testing shows these mattresses are ideal for:

Those looking for pressure relief. Foam mattresses are unparallelled in their ability to provide pressure relief, making them a favorite among those with chronic pain.

Those who want a high level of conforming. Foam beds, especially those with higher ratios of memory foam, will conform closely to the body.

Light sleepers. Foam mattresses isolate motion extremely well, so sleepers are less likely to wake up from noise or movement.

Couples. Foam mattresses sleep very quiet, although they can create a feeling of “fighting” the mattress during sex.

Budget shoppers. Foam mattresses have a low price-point, around $1,000 for a Queen, and are widely available.

Best Hybrid Mattresses

Mattress Reviews
WinkBeds Mattress Reviews
Mattress Reviews
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Mattress Review
Mattress Reviews
Tuft & Needle Mint Mattress Review
Mattress Reviews
DreamCloud Mattress Review

Hybrid Mattresses

Hybrid mattresses are a hybrid of innerspring and foam mattresses. They use individually pocketed coils in their support core, with at least 2 inches of memory foam or latex in their comfort layers.

Our testing shows these mattresses are ideal for:

Those looking for strong edge support. The support system is surrounded by a perimeter of polyfoam, ensuring strong edge support for those who like to sit on or sleep close to the edges of their bed.

Those who want a mix of conforming and responsiveness. Individually pocketed coils provide more contouring than an innerspring bed, while still being responsive for sex. The thickness and composition of the comfort layers ultimately determine the conforming of the mattress, with more memory foams equating to more conforming.

Back pain sufferers. The pocketed coils provide stabilizing support, while comfort layers relieve pressure. Plus, hybrid mattresses can feature zoned support systems, which are ideal for alleviating back pain.

Hot sleepers. The pocketed coil core supports airflow. Depending on the materials used in the comfort layers, some hybrid beds sleep cooler than others. Organic latex foams, or memory foams infused with gel, graphite, or copper offer better temperature neutrality.

Couples. Hybrids isolate motion fairly well, providing a quiet sleep surface, while still maintaining a good amount of responsiveness for sex.

Best Latex Mattresses

Mattress Reviews
Awara Mattress Review
Mattress Reviews
Avocado Mattress Review

Latex Mattresses

Latex mattresses use polyfoam or latex in their support core, with comfort layers of latex and other foams. Latex foam is formed using either the Dunlop or Talalay process. Dunlop has a denser feel, so it’s often used as a support layer, or in mattresses with higher firmness ratings. Talalay latex is fluffier and more common in comfort layers and softer mattresses.

Our testing shows these mattresses are ideal for:

Those interested in durability. Latex mattresses boast some of the longest lifespans, as they’re more resistant to sagging.

Heavier sleepers. Latex mattresses, especially those made from denser Dunlop latex, can provide long-lasting support for these individuals.

Hot sleepers. Latex mattresses sleep quite cool, especially if they contain a higher amount of natural latex.

Sleepers with allergies. All-latex mattresses are made with organic latex foams, which are naturally resistant to dust, mold, and bacteria.

Eco-conscious shoppers. Latex mattresses can be made almost entirely from organic materials (95% or more). In addition to using natural latex, these beds may also feature sustainably-sourced wool and organic cotton in their cover.

Airbed Mattresses

Airbeds have a support system of individual air chambers, topped by at least one comfort layer of foam. Sleepers can adjust the firmness of the bed by inflating or deflating it, using a manual crank or remote control.

Our testing shows these mattresses are ideal for:

Those interested in durability. Airbeds can last for a very long time, as long as you keep them well-maintained and regularly replace their parts.

Sleepers with changing firmness preferences. Sleepers can adjust the mattress whenever they want to achieve their ideal firmness level.

Couples. Airbeds minimize motion transfer to a significant extent, so reducing disruptions from a sleep partner shifting positions during the night.

Those looking for pressure relief. With their adjustable firmness, airbeds can provide good pressure relief, especially if they have thicker comfort layers.

Back pain sufferers. Sleepers can adjust the firmness level to create their ideal mix of support and pressure point relief.

Step 5: What’s Your Mattress Budget?

By now, you know what kind of mattress you want to buy. All that’s left is finding one that fits your budget.

Generally, a quality, Queen-size mattress costs anywhere from $1,000 to $2,000. Memory foam and innerspring mattresses tend to be more affordable, while latex, hybrid, and airbed models carry a more expensive price tag. The graph below lists the average price for the different types of mattresses.

Average Mattress Prices

In addition to the cost of the mattress itself, some manufacturers offer additional perks that increase the overall value of the mattress. These include:

Best Mattress FAQ

  • How Long Do Mattresses Last?

    Mattresses generally last somewhere between six and eight years. The lifespan of a mattress generally depends on the type and quality of materials it’s constructed with.

    There are a number of ways in which mattresses tend to deteriorate over time. One common symptom of an aging mattress is sagging, where parts of the mattress become uneven. Mattresses also tend to develop body impressions over time. Similarly, a bed will naturally get softer over time, which can lead to a lack of support.

    The least durable mattresses tend to be innerspring and all-foam mattresses, as springs are susceptible to sagging and foam develops body impressions. To ensure high durability for these mattress types, make sure to look for low gauge (thicker) coils in innersprings and high-density foam in all-foam models.

    Hybrids, containing both foam and springs, share the concerns of both former mattress types. That being said, this mattress type is less commonly sold at budget prices, and thus are generally built with higher quality materials.

    Finally, latex is known to be exceptionally durable, resisting sagging and body indentations longer than other mattress types. This is especially true of natural latex, rather than synthetic latex.

  • Do I Need a Box Spring or Foundation?

    While there are multiple reasons why one may want a box spring or foundation, having one won’t affect the overall comfort or feel of the mattress. Rather, foundations and box springs allow you things like having your mattress at a more optimal height, utilizing underbed storage, and altering the aesthetic of your bedroom.

  • What Mattress Size Should I Get?

    When considering which mattress size to get, the best starting point is figuring out how many bodies will be sleeping on it, how large everyone is, and how much space they require.

    Twin and twin XL mattresses are generally suited for only one person, regardless of body type. Taller people will likely prefer the extra length of a twin XL.

    Full mattresses can comfortably fit two smaller people, or one person and a pet.

    Queen mattresses are the most common mattress type, and are for two sleepers who like to have plenty of room. Queen mattresses can also fit a smaller pet.

    King mattresses are a luxury option for those who enjoy tons of space, although they may be a necessity for those with more than one co-sleeper (children, large dogs, etc.). California king mattresses are taller and narrower than king mattresses.

  • What is a Sleep Trail?

    Sleep trials are an essential part of the online mattress industry. Rather than laying on the bed in a store or relying purely on information online, sleep trials allow you to test the mattress in your own home for a set period. If you end up not liking it, the company will arrange for the mattress to be taken off your hands and you’ll be refunded.

    Sleep trial length varies by company, but they generally range from 30-365 nights. Some companies may charge you for shipping costs if you opt to take the refund.

  • What Does a Warranty Cover?

    Mattress warranties vary by brand and model, but they generally cover defects that are the result of errors on the manufacturer’s end, not the user’s.

    The most common warranty coverage is for premature sagging, which is often caused by faulty inner springs. Other common defects covered by most warranties include broken coils, undone seams, and irregular foam bunching.

    Users-inflicted issues and normal long term wear, on the other hand, generally aren’t covered by warranties. Mattress warranties usually last anywhere from 5-15 years.

  • What is White Glove Delivery?

    When you purchase a bed online, it may get shipped to your door in a box. Other brands offer White Glove Delivery, either for free or for an additional fee. With this service, representatives from the mattress company will deliver the mattress to your home, assemble it for you in your bedroom, and haul away your old mattress for recycling.

Table of Contents